Sustainable Business News (SBIZ)
c/o Squall Inc.
1101-945 Princess Street
Kingston, Ontario K7L 0E9

Beyond energy savings: Making the financial case for greener buildings

Speakers at Ottawa event say the financial risks of inaction need to be better reflected in commercial real estate valuations

Daryl Neate, vice-president of sustainability at REALPAC. (Simon Hopkins, Sustainable Biz Canada)

Reducing the environmental impact of commercial buildings is a priority for many owners and investors, but justifying the capital investments needed to do so can be challenging. As climate risks intensify, however, the financial case for inaction is becoming harder to ignore.

The financial risks of climate change and the need to better account for them in building valuations were central themes at a Nov. 10 forum hosted by The Better Buildings Breakfast in Ottawa, titled The Green Building Balance Sheet.

Darryl Neate, vice-president of sustainability at REALPAC, an association representing Canadian commercial real estate owners and investors, said property valuations need to better account for climate-related risks.

“Climate-related risks are real estate risks,” Neate said in his presentation about climate risk and asset valuation. “Owners aren't short on ambition; they're short on business cases,” he said.

He outlined two types of climate risks: transition risks, which can reduce building values through changing market demand, low-carbon regulations and increased insurance costs; and physical risks, which include climate-related threats such as flooding and extreme heat.

Owners can mitigate these risks by reducing emissions to meet evolving regulatory requirements and adapting buildings to protect occupants from climate-related hazards.

Inaction has financial consequences

Renée Pichard, an independent financial advisor and accountant, warned that inaction carries its own financial risks. “Inaction is costly,” she said. She pointed to the financial consequences of failing to prepare for extreme weather events and other emergencies. “If resilience hasn't been baked into the portfolio, into the assets, then there will be significant financial consequences down the road,” Pichard said.

According to a report published in May by REALPAC and the Canada Green Building Council, extreme weather was responsible for $8.5 billion in insured losses in 2024. The report, called Valuing the future, stated that while climate risks are impacting businesses, valuations do not yet reflect a building’s resiliency to climate risks. The report provides guidance for the Appraisal Institute of Canada to adopt new standards for considering sustainability in valuation.

The speakers argued that climate resilience needs to be included in asset value.

Neate explained that efforts to make the business case for green retrofits have traditionally focused on the cost savings associated with more energy-efficient buildings. Asked by Sustainable Biz Canada how the financial costs of climate change could factor into investment decisions, Neate said the prospect of increased revenue could provide another incentive for owners to undertake green retrofits. “If people are paying more for low-carbon buildings, I think that will move the needle,” he said.

“If I electrify my heating plant, am I going to get more on the value of my building? The current answer is unfortunately not likely.”

There is currently no clear rental premium for decarbonized buildings, Neate said, with low-carbon and conventional spaces often commanding similar rents. However, he said decarbonization can still offer a financial upside by helping building owners protect rental income.

"We may not be getting more rent for a green building today, but we are protecting against the erosion of rents,” he said. “The stronger connection to value at this point is protecting against eroding rents than driving strong rents.”

Data and disclosure could be improved

Another barrier to decarbonizing buildings is data sharing. According to Afaf Azzouz, director of sustainability and climate at Deloitte, building owners and tenants don't always have a complete understanding of a building's energy and emissions performance. Tenants may pay utility bills and have their own emission reduction targets, while landlords are responsible for justifying and financing building retrofits.

Azzouz said data and analytics can help building owners make the case for decarbonization investments and determine when equipment should be replaced based on performance rather than age.

“If you start looking at, either virtual or actual sub metering capabilities, looking at power factor changes, vibration, heat changes, you can move from predictive to proactive maintenance.”

REALPAC has also called for the improvement of data sharing, especially around utility data. In its 2024 report, Decarbonizing Canada's Commercial Buildings, REALPAC identified limited access to utility data as one of six key barriers to decarbonization, noting that owners often struggle to obtain the information needed to report building performance to investors.



Industry Events